Election 2016: Mitchell McKinney, MU Expert, Says First GOP Debate Was Helpful

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

On Thursday, August 6, the first Republican presidential primary debate was held in Cleveland, Ohio. Now, Mitchell S. McKinney, professor of political communication at the University of Missouri, and a nationally and internationally recognized scholar of presidential debates, offers his remarks on the debate.

"For the most part, this first debate of the leading Republican candidates was a useful discussion of a number of significant campaign issues that demonstrated key differences among the contenders on a range of important topics," McKinney said. "The Fox News team handled the large field of candidates very well and didn't shy away from tough questioning of the candidates."

McKinney suggests that one of the winners of the Republican debate was Democratic frontrunner Hilary Clinton.

"Perhaps one of the winners of tonight's debate was Hillary Rodham Clinton. While a few of the candidates made passing references to the Democratic frontrunner, several of these attacks were lighthearted in nature. Interestingly, the leading Republican candidates were much more aggressive in taking on the incumbent president than their attacks directed toward the Democratic frontrunner," McKinney said. "The treatment of Clinton in the main debate was in stark contrast to the many more pointed attacks she received in the second-tier candidate debate that took place earlier in the afternoon, particularly the 'no-holds-barred' approach to Clinton by Carly Fiorina whose earlier performance earned her a cameo appearance—along with Rick Perry—in the main show."

Donald Trump, the often divisive Republican frontrunner, was expected to "steal the show." However, McKinney contends that his performance was somewhat muted.

"This debate did not become the 'Donald Trump show' as many had predicted and even feared," McKinney said. "In fact, on several occasions the Fox panelists encouraged the candidates to take on Mr. Trump; yet repeatedly Trump's opponents declined to do so. Because of this apparent unwillingness to attack Mr. Trump, he didn't receive much response time and therefore we heard from nearly all the candidates equally without Donald Trump monopolizing the debate.

For his performance, Mr. Trump demonstrated appropriate fury and rage in his responses – perhaps the only exception was his calling all political leaders in the United States 'stupid,' but otherwise he projected an aggressiveness that many voters may find appealing. Trump did seem more concerned with the viewers and voters in the wider public audience and not the Republican party faithful that made up the debate hall crowd. Finally, Mr. Trump didn't seem to shy away from his previous positions and bold pronouncements; he appeared to survive this first debate with his frontrunner status intact."

McKinney also critiqued Jeb Bush's performance.

"As the principal contender to Mr. Trump for reigning frontrunner status, Jeb Bush's debate performance this evening was rather 'low key' at times, almost too relaxed to the point of being diminished by the much more aggressive Trump who was standing next to Bush," McKinney said. "While Gov. Bush's strategy may be to highlight a thoughtful and reasoned demeanor compared to the brasher and boastful Trump, voters may desire to see a more energetic and aggressive Jeb Bush in future debates."

McKinney also is director of the Political Communication Institute at MU (http://pci.missouri.edu). His research has focused particular attention on presidential primary debates, with his analysis indicating that a candidate's debate performance at this formative stage of the campaign can greatly enhance – or hinder – one's ability to emerge as the eventual nominee. His research concluded candidates approach their primary debate performances much differently than candidates engaged in general-election debates. In his research, McKinney has found that viewers actually find these early debate encounters much more useful than those presidential debates that occur toward the end of a long campaign.


Mitchell McKinney, professor of political communication at the University of Missouri, and a nationally and internationally recognized scholar of presidential debates, has written his post-mortem on last night's debate and its participants and offers his unique views in the attached critique.

Haute Tease

  • Celebrity Interview: Talking with Armie Hammer on Final Portrait, Geoffrey Rush and Inspiration

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Armie Hammer, who's star power is seriously on the rise, is becoming quite well known and after his award nominated performance in Call Me By Your Name, is their anywhere on the planet where he isn't recognized?

  • Salome and Wild Salome Review – Powerhouse Performances, Solid Writing, Drive This Adaptation

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Salome, from Salome Productions, presents the Oscar Wilde adaptation of the events leading up to the beheading of John the Baptist and how Tetrarch's indiscretion force him to pay for his glib and cavalier offer.

  • Suicide Squad Review - The Most Diverse Superhero Cast Yet

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    The much anticipated "Suicide Squad," a villainous take on the classic superhero movie, opens in theaters on August 5th. Despite some early negative reviews, the third film in the DC Extended Universe franchise is still poised to open at around $140 million and has already broken Fandango's pre-sale ticket record for August.  

  • PENFOLDS launched its latest collection of wines; Russell Crowe Narrates Grange Vintage Film

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    PENFOLDS launched its latest collection of wines at the China pavilion in Shanghai, giving a strong indication of where the iconic winemaker believes the market has shifted for luxury products.

  • Easier With Practice, a Kyle Patrick Alvarez Film, Provocatively Challenges Sexual Taboos

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Easier with Practice, a provocative challenging contemporary film, crosses sexual boundaries and explores sexual taboos with the determination, honesty and openness, of the1960’s generation.

  • Beltway Insider: Obama Loyal to France; Hollande Declares War, Airstrikes Begin; G20; Charlie Sheen

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    President Obama announced his unwavering support for President Hollande and the people of France in the wake of the coordinated terror strikes that shocked the civilized world and accelerated the coalition nation's determination to eradicate terrorism.

  • Reba Merrill: The Tinsel Town Talker Predicts Oscar Winners and Breaks Open The Archives For a Treat

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Roll out the red carpet, get some fancy clothes add some champagne and you’re ready for your Oscar party. The best part is to win as many categories as possible so to impress your friends with your Hollywood connections.

  • Open Heart Review – Hope in the Dimmest of Places

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Open Heart,” from HBO Pictures and Producer Abigail Disney, follows eight children diagnosed with Rheumatic Heart Disease as they travel from remote Rwanda to the Sudan to receive high risk life saving medical treatment.

  • Monkey King San Diego Review - Unique History; Delicious Chinese Cuisine, Late-Night Dining

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    San Diego's famed Gaslamp Quarter, a bustling community filled with vibrant nightlife, which unquestionably includes dining options. Amid the burgeoning downtown culinary scene is Monkey King, an elegant late-night Chinese cuisine eatery that opened its doors in late 2017.

  • 99 Homes Review – Riveting Performances Captures the Emotions of the Foreclosure Crisis

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    99 Homes, from Broad Green Pictures, presents a stunning portrayal of contemporary life in post-recession America, where decent people, once solid home owners, are suddenly ambushed by a corrupt judicial system as they struggle to save their dying American dream.

  • 70 ISIS Associates Named Across 21 States

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Sky News, the British News Agency, has announced a former Islamic State Fighter has leaked tens of thousands of documents revealing the names and global locations of at least 22,000 recruited members of the terrorist organization.

  • Southern California Hit with Significant Earthquake (TIPS)

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    A 6.4 magnitude earthquake, the strongest to hit the region in two decades, struck Southern California at about 10:33 AM, July 4, 2019, signaling to skittish SoCal residents the relative quiet period has ended and to expect significant aftershocks.

  • Curls Hair Care Creator Celebrates a Decade in Business

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Mahisha Dellinger, CURLS hair care founder and creator, has for the past ten years embraced the ethnic hair care market, running riglet's around her competition with her Curls brand product line.

  • Cottage and Bungalow - Perfect Luxurious Decor for the Summer Home

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Cottage and Bungalow, the luxury home décor company, offers American made handcrafted coastal furniture, beach décor and accessories crafted from driftwood, seashells, and other types of luxury items are the perfect complement for any the summer home.

  • Op/Ed: Sacrificing Freedom to Vaccination

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    The Oath of Hippocrates states physicians have the duty to advise their patients according to the best of their ability and judgment. Physicians usually recommend vaccination, believing that for a particular patient, the benefit exceeds the risk.