World News: Our Lady Tempted by The Private

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

The fire of Notre-Dame de Paris raises the issue of funding the maintenance of religious buildings under the control of an indebted state and tempted by the call to private to save a heritage time counted.

Past the controversies over the donations dedicated to the financing of the renovation work of Notre Dame de Paris, polemics typically French and which have not finished punctuating the upcoming comments on the future renovation, arises also and above all an essential question: What about the state of national cultural heritage and how in the years to come will the state contribute to its maintenance?

From the outset, let us dispel some of the prejudices, namely that a large part of the heritage is of private essence and that their owners are responsible for it. But with regard to the public heritage (with exception), including religious buildings (church, cathedral, temple, mosque and synagogue), the problem is quite different.

Beltway Insider: Easter Sunday Massacre, Mueller Report, Notre Dame Fire/Yellow Vests, Pope Francis

A legal and historical reminder is needed. In France, since the promulgation of the law on the Separation of Churches and the State in 1905, religious buildings are under the responsibility of the State which ensures the maintenance and the inherent risks (the fire of Notre Dame is the typical example). In this case, the state is its own insurer.

Proof of Time and Public Finances

However, this legacy has become all the more cumbersome as over the years, the heritage in question is subject to the test of time and the public finances, supposed to provide the funds necessary for their maintenance, are subject to the deficit test ...

Historic Notre Dame Cathedral Destroyed

Some would argue that it is economically necessary to privatize all or part of this heritage in measures specific to each building, measures that should be fixed. "Horror! Would say the fierce defenders of a heritage under the control of the community. The argument of dispossession for the benefit of the private sector is audible, understandable and legitimate and it is up to everyone to know whether he is welcome or not.

For example, remember that the Eiffel Tower, a non-religious but private building, posted a revenue of 100 million euros in 2018 when Notre Dame de Paris presented a balance sheet amounting to 10 million, the faithful are refusing to privatize the entrance of the 12th century cathedral.

This decision, to the credit of those who have taken it, does not prevent the question of the recourse to the private sector will necessarily arise with more and more acuity in the coming years to finance the renovation work. Because if the subscriptions launched its last days for the renovation of the cathedral are public initiatives, the funds collected are private gasoline.

Debt and Doxa

There are several reasons for thinking. Starting with the cost of maintaining and renovating the buildings. If the Ministry of Culture is generous, the Ministry of Economy is not necessarily in view of current and future budget constraints.

World News: The Yellow Vest Movement Showing Signs of Fading

And if the cost remains so far negligible compared to the state budget (nearly 2.500 billion euros of which nearly 98% absorbed by the repayment of the public debt), this cost could experience a high inflation with regard to heritage wear accelerated by global warming. Another reason, which ignores the collective doxa that the heritage remains in the state (thus confirming the link between the French and the physical remains of their history), the relative ease with which it is possible to mobilize private funds.

Relative because all religious buildings are not worth Notre Dame and it will be more difficult to mobilize millions of euros for a chapel unknown to the general public for Notre Dame ....

A true cultural revolution that is announced and raised by the renovation of Notre-Dame whose greatness has passed through the ages but whose vicissitudes sends a country to economic realities that the fire has brought out.

World News: Emmanuel Macron Faces His Defining Test

And if for now, get rid of supporters and detractors of private or public funding, will inevitably come time for the decision for Notre Dame and for other buildings: Private or public?



Bio: Olivier Longhi has extensive experience in European history. A seasoned journalist with fifteen years of experience, he is currently professor of history and geography in the Toulouse region of France. He has held a variety of publishing positions, including Head of Agency and Chief of Publishing. A journalist, recognized blogger, editor and editorial project manager, he has trained and managed editorial teams, worked as a journalist for various local radio stations, a press and publishing consultant, and a communications consultant.

Haute Tease

  • Beltway Insider: Obama/Syrian Policy Failure; Gun Violence; Election 2016; Bill Cosby

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    President Barack Obama has returned to Washington from his Holiday and is eager and energized to begin his last year in office moving ahead with the Gun Violence issue he has indicated the intent to announce Executive Order action.

  • The Music of Strangers: Yo-Yo Ma and The Silk Road Ensemble Review – Bravo, Magnifique, A Masterpiece

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    The Music of Strangers: Yo-Yo Ma and The Silk Road Ensemble, from The Orchard and Participant Media, debuted at the Los Angeles Film Festival, to rave reviews of the power of music, in all its forms, to bridge cultural differences and divides.

  • Paris Fashion Week: Rani Zakhem Couture, Fall/Winter 2018-2019 – Dazzling, Flamboyant, Sensual

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    The Rani Zakhem Couture Fall Winter 2018-2019 collection is a vibrant, sparkling tribute to the combating and combative woman, Amazone of all jungles and terribly "Glamazonian", fatally seductive when, like a warrior goddess, she appears in her crystal armor.

  • Call Me By Your Name Review – Beautiful; Well Crafted Story of Discovery

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Call Me By Your Name, from Sony Pictures Classic, presents a story that could be taboo, scandalous, a journey of awakenings in the 1980’s as a friendship takes on a life of its own leading to romance, love, and acceptance.

  • Velentine's Day Gift Guide: Luscious Valentine’s Day Gifts with Direct-to-Door Delivery

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Chocolate, recent statistics show, accounted for nearly 59 percent of U.S. candy retail sales for the six weeks before Valentine's Day in 2016. That’s a lot of sweet treats duly expressing our love and adoration for the darlings in our lives.  

  • Smithsonian Channel Celebrates 100th Anniversary Of The National Park Service With New One-Hour Special

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Fill up the Mini-Van, load the camping gear, hit the highway and settle in for a summer of fun, travel, and unforgettable adventures or just tune in Sunday, August 28 at 8p.m. for AMERICA'S NATIONAL PARKS AT 100.

  • Beltway Insider: Trump/Davos, Greta Thunberg, Impeachment Arguments, Auschwitz, Jim Lehrer, Election 2020

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    President Trump has apparently resigned his inability to control the impeachment hearings and has decided to adopt a business as usual attitude, appearing at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, as his impeachment trial begins.

  • Beltway Insider: Trump Implodes; UK/Russia; Parkland Killer/Student WalkOut; Matt Damon; Stephen Hawking

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    The ENOUGH Movement, birthed from the Marjory Douglas Stoneman High School Massacre, organized a National Walkout across America, in every city as they dedicated themselves to ending gun violence in our schools and remembering those senselessly killed.

  • You Were Never Really Here Review – Joaquin Phoenix Delivers a Heart Stopping Performance

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    You Were Never Really Here, from Amazon Studios, British Film Institute, Film 4 and Why Not Productions, presents the story of a traumatized former soldier who stateside becomes the search and rescue muscle to a private investigator.

  • STEP Review – An Uplifting, Triumphant, Docu-Drama

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    STEP, from Fox Searchlight Pictures, presents a documentary drama that showcases the first graduating class of the Baltimore Charter School, the effort the girls make to meet the challenges, and the dance team that unites them.

  • Sony Entertainment and Columbia Pictures Host SALT Junket in Washington, D.C.

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    SALT, a Sony Entertainment/Columbia Pictures film recently hosted its press junket which included a debut screening of the film, followed by an exclusive reception with panel discussion at The International Spy Museum and a Spy City Tour of espionage hot spots in Washington, DC.

  • Mick Jones Opens Library; Releases Limited Edition Instrumental Album

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Mick Jones of The Clash, one of the most established and respected figures in British pop music, has opened his Rock and Roll Public Library as part of the 56th Venice Biannale releasing a very limited edition of up tempo instrumentals called 'Ex Libris'.

  • Interview: Analyst, Author, George Carneal, Weighs in on The New Face of The Democratic Party (Q&A)

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Welcome to the new face of the Democratic Party with a White openly gay ex-small-town mayor leading who might become the youngest U.S. President in history, followed by a white openly Socialist White 78-year old.

  • Pacific Opera Project takes on Shakespeare and Verdi in a Cemetery with Falstaf

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    This September, Pacific Opera Project (POP) continues its successful run of presenting engaging productions in unique venues across Los Angeles with Giuseppe Verdi’s Falstaff, presented outdoors at the top of Forest Lawn Memorial Park (Museum Plaza) in Glendale.  

  • Beltway Insider: Trump/Putin Vaca; Mueller’s Grand Jury; North Korea; Minnesota Extremism; Solar Eclipse; Sam Shepard

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    President Donald Trump has left the building and relocated for a working vacation over the next seventeen days to his Southern Jersey Golf Course, while the White House West Wing undergoes much needed and previously approved renovations.