HL Business: Thirty Companies That Might Disappear in 2017

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Tim Boyle / Getty Images

It's one thing to predict the next Google, Facebook or Uber -- the hot companies of the future that will define the next decade of enterprise and investing. But what about predicting the next Borders or Blockbuster? Sometimes big business flops can be just as spectacular as corporate success stories.

In the 1960s, New York University Professor Edward Altman set out to do just that. He devised a four-part formula -- based entirely on publicly available financials -- to predict which companies would go bankrupt within two years. The formula produced a single number for each company, called the Altman Z-Score. According to a 2000 study, the score successfully predicted bankruptcy between 80 and 90 percent of the time up through 1999.

FindTheCompany, a corporate research site from Graphiq, used Altman Z-Scores to do the same analysis for 2016 companies. In order to qualify for the list, companies had to have a market capitalization of at least $100 million. In the end, the team identified 30 large companies, including several household brands, at risk of bankruptcy in the near future. They can be seen in the table below.

Altman considered companies with an Altman Z-Score over 2.6 "safe," companies with a score between 1.1 and 2.6 in a "gray" zone, and companies with a score under 1.1 "at risk."

In brief, the formula considers the following factors:

  • Working Capital / Total Assets: companies with a low or negative score here will struggle to pay bills on time

  • Retained Earnings / Total Assets: companies that rely on large amounts of debt and borrowing receive a low or negative score here

  • Earnings Before Interest & Taxes (EBIT) / Total Assets: companies that bring in a small amount of revenue relative to their size receive low or negative scores

  • Book Value of Equity / Total Liabilities: a low or negative ratio here indicates that the company may be using debt to finance growth, which can often lead to bankruptcy

Last year, FindTheCompany named 10 "at risk" companies, based on the Altman Z-Score. Two -- Aeropostale and Quiksilver -- wound up going bankrupt. Still, the numbers say all the companies on this year's list have reason to be concerned.

Shortcomings of the Altman Z-Score

Naturally, the formula isn't perfect. The Altman Z-Score doesn't do the best job accounting for deferred revenue, which can make software companies in particular look worse off than they really are.

The score also relies on data directly from each company, so it's only as good as the data the corporation provides.

Additionally, some companies will perform a one-time write-off, potentially as part of a failed acquisition. This can result in a very low Altman Z-Score for a particular year or quarter, which might be unrepresentative of a company's long-term position.

Finally, keep in mind that companies can go bankrupt, then restructure and emerge in a stronger position.

Trends in the List

Computer and technology companies make the most appearances on the list, with nine total corporations at risk. Part of this speaks to the volatility of tech firms, which can grow at record rates, then fall at the hands of a disruptive competitor.

That said, it's possible the Altman Z-Score struggles to understand certain aspects of tech companies, which we'll explore in a few specific examples below.

Meanwhile, medical companies (including both instrument makers and pharmaceutical firms) and retail companies (like J.C. Penney and Sears) appear the next-most frequently, which speaks to the ongoing decline of the sector alongside the continued rise of e-commerce.

Hello Again: J.C. Penney, Sprint and Sears

Three familiar names return to the list from last year. J.C. Penney is at least no worse off, with revenue up slightly year over year, and share prices holding steady around $8 since early 2015. It's a far cry from the company's 2007 height (when shares hit $85), but it represents some welcome stabilization for a corporation destroyed by the 2008 financial crisis.

Meanwhile, Sprint saw declining revenue despite adding more subscribers. The problem? Sprint's biggest competitors are adding subscribers faster. In August of last year, the company fell to No. 4 in the country's carrier rankings, ceding third place to T-Mobile (Verizon and AT&T are first and second, respectively).

Sears has arguably fared the worst of the three since last year. In April, the company announced plans to to close 68 Kmarts and 10 Sears this summer, a decision that came after a parade of poor results in quarterly earnings. Sales have declined for the corporation every year since 2005.

A Long Rise, A Quick Fall

Among other retail consumer brands, The Container Store joins the list of at-risk corporations. Founder and CEO Kip Tindell founded the company way back in 1978, gradually building the business through 2013, when it went public. Shares doubled in value shortly after. Still, sales momentum has slowed since 2010, flattening out through 2014 and 2015. Tindell will step down as CEO on July 1, amid growing competition from Walmart, IKEA and e-retailers like Amazon.

Overstated? Applied Micro Circuits and Viavi Solutions

The Altman Z-Score likely overstates the problems at Applied Micro Circuits and Viavi Solutions. Each received an extremely negative score, largely due to highly negative retained earnings / assets.

Some companies will reinvest almost all profits back into the business in an effort to grow quickly, which can create a low or negative score in the retained earnings category. This sort of behavior is typical of startups and early stage private companies, but less so for public companies, which have an obligation to make money for investors.

Still, modern tech companies are often different than traditional, infrastructure-heavy companies, which were more dominant in Altman's time. As such, don't assume either of these companies will go out of business next week.

To be fair, Viavi Solutions has given investors a few reasons to be nervous over the past year -- including a company restructuring and CEO departure that saw a steep stock price drop -- but these moves alone shouldn't be enough to cause alarm.

It's quite possible that several tech companies will disappear from this list by this time next year. The only question is whether it will be from rebounding financials...or financial insolvency.

Explore More Than 30M Companies on FindTheCompany

Haute Tease

  • HL London: Champagne & Chocolate Tasting at Champagne+Fromage Shop & Bistro with Paul.a.Young Fine Chocolate

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Join us for this unique tasting experience at our Champagne Bistro in Covent Garden where we try to discover the best combinations of amazing chocolates created by Paul A Young in person with a selection of different Champagne styles.

  • Money News: Twenty Best Tech Funds That Hold FANG

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Given the innovation and success of many tech giants, it's understandable why investing in the tech sector is so appealing. Growth for the largest companies such as Facebook, Amazon, Netflix and Google or FANG investing has been impressive, beating out all the major market indices.

  • Table 926 Restaurant San Diego Review - Locavore Love At First Bite

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    If you're someone who seeks to exclusively or primarily eat foods that are locally produced or sourced within relatively close proximity to your home and not moved long distances to market, than it's official…you're a "locavore"!

  • DNA Found In Soil Samples Pinpoints Neanderthal Existence

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    After an exhausted archaeological expedition, covering two continents and spanning seven sites, geneticist Viviane Slon and her team collected seven samples which they believed would lead to a new discovery on the existence of prehistoric mammals.

  • La France de Macron et la France des Gilets Jaunes

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    La crise des Gilets Jaunes révèle l'existence de deux France que beaucoup oppose : Principes, histoire, croyances, ambition. Ni l'une ni l'autre ne cédera. Et l'issue de la crise de peut-être se trouver dans la disparition de l'un des deux.  

  • Charlie Says - Haunting, Shocking Even After 50 Years

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Charlie Says, from IFC Films, brings to the screen an intimate look at the Manson Family Cult, through the eyes of the three women who lived with him, loved him, believed his lunacy and ultimately murdered for him.

  • Seal Pup Slaughter Begins

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    As the Seal pup slaughter is set to begin, The International Humane Society and the Humane Society United States (HSUS) have initiated an on-going effort to stop the barbaric massacre on the Canadian Ice Floes.

  • Don’t Let Go Review – Mind Bending Psychological Thriller Delivers

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Don’t Let Go, from Blumhouse Productions and Universal Pictures, brings to the screen a psychological drama, set in contemporary Los Angeles, as a detective receives the chance to stop the murder of his niece.

  • Beltway Insider: The Affordable Care Act Controversy Continues; October Job Numbers; Christie’s Big Win; Key Election Results

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    President Obama, stinging from several weeks of continued criticism over the failures of the Affordable Care Act Marketplace website and the less than forthcoming data from the White House, took to the road this week to pitch the plan.

  • Cannes Yachting Festival – New Waves of Inspiration With Elegance and Comfort

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    At the Cannes Yachting Festival, Berret Racoupeau's yacht design team will present their four most recent production designs: the Amel 50, the Wauquiez PS 42, the Saona and the Océanis 51, as well as other construction projects and one-off designs.

  • Business News: The Evaporating American Homeownership Dream Verses Higher Education

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Picture a home of your own, a white-picket fence, front porch, yard or view. Sound like a fairy tale? Homeownership appears increasingly elusive to a large population subset, but a whopping 72% or $8.74 trillion of U.S. debt is mortgage-related, according to MarketWatch.  

  • Haute Home: The Brand Best Equipped to Become the Smart Home King

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Sixteen years after the Disney Channel released the spooky, made-for-TV movie “Smart House,” the film now seems positively prophetic. Complete with voice commands, temperature control and a pleasant, Siri-like response system, Disney nailed several of the next decade’s tech breakthroughs. It’s as if the filmmakers knew we’d get Nest, Google Now and Apple TV in just a few short years.

  • ZAGROS, the First Feature Film From Belgian-Kurdish Director Sahim Omar Kalifa, Selected for Dubai International Film Festival

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    ZAGROS, the first feature film from Belgian-Kurdish director Sahim Omar Kalifa,  will be presented in the prestigious Muhr Feature Competition at this year's Dubai International Film Festival which opens December 5 through December 14, 2017.  

  • Tribute and Damage - Have We Lost Sight of the Lessons of History

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    The end of the celebrations of the centenary of the First World War have passed and does not leave without questioning the relations, the interactions, of the French to History. And if they had simply changed?

  • HL Tech Biz Exclusive: Is Tim Cook's Apple Past Its Peak

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Following Apple’s first down quarter in over a decade and mixed reviews for the company’s recent Worldwide Developers Conference, an ominous question is making the rounds.