The Circle Review – The Story of Ernest Ostertag and Robi Rapp Highlight Hard Won Freedoms

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

"The Circle," the Swiss official selection for the 87th Academy Award, presents the story of Röbi Rapp and Ernst Ostertag, who after decades of living openly in the shadows, became the first same-sex couple to register for domestic partnership.


Directed by Stefan Haupt, "The Circle," a docu-drama, stars Ernst Ostertag as Matthias Hungerbühler, and Röbi Rapp as Sven Schelker, as the film chronicles the relationship beginning in the 1930's as the two were young, gay and naive in an even younger Switzerland.

"The Circle," brings the viewer into the lives of the openly "gay underground." Even as homosexuality was not illegal, it was almost the "don't ask don't tell" military policy of the Clinton era. Homosexuals were concerned with the possibility of losing employment, or other inalienable rights guaranteed to all and voiced the concern.

"The Circle" introduces the small group of men as they fight for gay rights as members the legendary Der Kreis, The Circle, an organization which published a periodical uniting Switzerland's fragile yet vibrant post-WWII gay community. 

A docu-drama, elements of the "The Circle" is scripted part of the fictionalized lifestyle as documented through memories or journals, and then woven with actual interview sequences by the subjects and living relatives and other who were involved or affected.

The murders inched closer to the group it wasn't until an inner circle member was murdered and the details of his life, frequenting prostitutes or "rent boys," an open support of a liberal pre-AIDS gay lifestyle bordered on vicious.  

As the events are presented, a string of unsolved gay murders brought a spotlight on the publication and other gathering places and became the cause of unnecessary outings which ended badly for many, even in liberal Switzerland.

The unsolved murder became the crux for the police to raid the gay clubs and force those who were secret into the open destroying lives indiscriminately.  

"The Circle" is more than a documentary, more a docu-drama with news footage, personal memorabilia interwoven with scripted action and personal interviews. It surprisingly details a permissiveness culture that suddenly decides boundaries are necessary. It's descriptive and revealing.

Equality is hard won fight as the story of Switzerland's first same sex couple to marry comes to the light it is filled with the skeletons and memories of those who fell along the way in pursuit of the freedom to be.

Select media were invited to meet the director and the two men who are the focus of the documentary at a media brunch held at the Park Avenue residence of the Swiss Consulate.

Ernst Ostertag and Röbi Rapp, have the dynamics of any couple who have had such a long life together. They were kind, friendly and honestly adorable. If one did not know they story, one could not have imagined these two elderly, well spoken, gentlemen where a part of an international movement that, through diligent persistence, and simply living a committed life, were in actuality the subject of the film.

In some ways, the film is reminiscent of taboo subjects one would have with ones parents. There are just some things you don't talk about and the youthful indulgences of an aging parent who lived openly practicing any type of sexuality is one of them. Even as adults when children believe any subject is approachable as "we're all adults here" there are simply boundaries.

"The Circle" does contain gay sexual illustrations and full frontal nudity. It depicts a gay lifestyle, which after youthful wanderings, settles into an almost mundane existence of life and love. The two men built a life together when the possibility was non-existent and lived freely, openly, and struggled with the issues of family responsibilities and is the truth necessary if the harm is irreparable?

"The Circle" is Switzerland's Official Submission for Foreign Language Film at the 87thAcademy Awards® and Winner of Panorama Audience Award at 2014 Berlin International Film Festival, Teddy Award at 2014 Berlin International Film Festival and Grand Jury Award at 2014 Outfest.

Not seen simply as a gay film "The Circle" truly presents a piece of history which should be seen for many reasons.

"The Circle"is plying in select cities. Check local listings.

Haute Tease

  • Air Head Alert: ABC Hires Former Playboy Playmate to Co-Host The View

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Jenny McCarthy, former Playboy model and frequent guest host for the popular daytime talk show, “The View,” has been given a permanent host position in the wake of the departure of conservative Elizabeth Hasselbeck.

  • Trailer Of Belgian Debut 'Coureur' To Premiere At Rotterdam Film Festival's Limelight Programme

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    The Belgian feature film 'Coureur,' the semi-autobiographical debut by Kenneth Mercken, will have its international premiere in the 'Limelight' programme of the 'Voices' section at the 48th International Film Festival of Rotterdam (23 Jan - 3 Feb).

  • HL Tech Biz Exclusive: Is Tim Cook's Apple Past Its Peak

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Following Apple’s first down quarter in over a decade and mixed reviews for the company’s recent Worldwide Developers Conference, an ominous question is making the rounds.  

  • Money News: DOW, World Markets Close Up; Nikkei Sinks

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    The DOW Jones Industrial Average, as well as nine of the top ten world markets, rallied as investor confidence once again returned, to the global stage, with economies and markets exhibiting strong gains across the board.

  • Beltway Insider: Obama and The Panama Papers Fall Out; Election 2016; Journos Murdered; Elon Musk; Zaha Hadid

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    President Obama began his post presidency employment search this week with a stopover at University of Chicago Law School where he taught an introductory course to which he was well received. His tenure is still under consideration.

  • Monkey King San Diego Review - Unique History; Delicious Chinese Cuisine, Late-Night Dining

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    San Diego's famed Gaslamp Quarter, a bustling community filled with vibrant nightlife, which unquestionably includes dining options. Amid the burgeoning downtown culinary scene is Monkey King, an elegant late-night Chinese cuisine eatery that opened its doors in late 2017.

  • Denzel Washington To Receive 47th AFI Life Achievement Award

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    The American Film Institute (AFI) Board of Trustees announced that Denzel Washington will receive the 47th AFI Life Achievement Award, America's highest honor for a career in film. The tribute will premiere on TNT with an encore on Turner Classic Movies.  

  • PT’s Entertainment Group to Host Grand Opening Celebration for New PT’s Gold Location

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    PT's Entertainment Group will commemorate the grand opening of its 60th tavern, PT's Gold, located at 8985 Blue Diamond Road, with a celebration including discounts on food and drinks from 5 to 10 p.m. on Thursday, Aug. 30.  

  • Coming Out in Hollywood

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Recently, The Wrap wrote a really insightful article about celebrities coming out publicly with ease, yet there are certain industries where it is still taboo to be out of the closet, namely big movie stars.

  • Nearly 400 Accidents in Four Hours As Rain Snarls LA's Morning Commute

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Over a four hour time period, Southern California Highway Patrol reported 365 car accidents were called in by shell-shocked LA drivers as the forecasted torrential rains disrupted the Thursday morning commute snarling the already bumper-to-bumper traffic.

  • Uma Information Technology Names Michael Schneglberger Chief Operating Officer

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Uma, the leading innovator in semantic web technology today announced that it has appointed Michael Schneglberger as chief operating officer.

  • Celebrity Interview: The Real Dish on Bravo’s First Real Housewife Alex McCord

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    For Alex McCord and her hotelier husband Simon van Kempen, the roles of reality TV stars on Bravo's hit series, "The Real Housewives of New York" is not something they ever expected and initially turned down.

  • Brew Hop Tours San Diego Review - A Failsafe Destination for the Ultimate Any Day Gift

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    Let's face it for some Dads, gifting a tie, a bottle of aftershave or a pair of slippers for Father’s Day just won’t do. And a belated gift or “fallback” card from a drugstore carousel reeks of desperation, or utter laziness. For many men, life is all about experiences and beer, lots and lots of beer.  

  • Bloody Friday: Two School Shootings Leave 11 Dead, 13 Injured

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    American's plague of gun violence claimed eleven lives Friday at two school shootings, in Santa Fe, Texas and Jonesboro, Georgia, marking the deadliest day of violence since the February 14 Parkland massacre at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School.

  • CES 2016: Smart Cars Debut Preview Future of the High Tech Automobile

    AddThis Social Bookmark Button

    There is no better place to witness the future of the automotive industry than at CES. Held annually in Las Vegas, CES, or the Consumer Electronics Show, is the largest event in the consumer electronics industry, with over 170,000 attendees.